Thuvia’s working for me.

I’ve been rereading them Mars books, all out of order of course. Princess was first, and my last read before the movie. If I’m too close it’ll mess up the flick for me. Then I read Chessmen. Chessmen is one of the longer ones which is great. What sort of drags for me are the long conversations about who did what to who ( Tan Sabfuf insulted Sab Tanfuf of the kingdom Fufanfuf ) and I just roll up my eyes – when I come to, I flip ahead to Ghek or Tara stabbing someone. It takes WAAAAY to long to get to the jetan games. So what I was reminded of concerning ERB’s writing is when he’s describing stuff, he’s great, when the characters are outside and running around Barsoom, that works for me. And of course when the action’s on it’s peddle to the metal. But when they’re inside a palace or something… I can’t get past envisioning a Flash Gordon episode including curtains for walls and long speeches because they don’t ——— sorry I knocked off there for a moment. They don’t have a budget. So I read the good parts. It think the book needs more than one jetan game in it and less court intrigue. But I must say that I became truly misty near the end, when on the jetan field Tara says She would trust Gahan with her life.

So far Thuvia is all good parts. The palace stuff is actually about the characters, the pacing is right and for some reason the settings are large and interesting with lots going on. Not a curtained wall in sight. the description of the bad guy entering Helium and walking the streets is really interesting stuff. What’s also interesting is that ERB’s description of Helium isn’t anything like what’s in my head. He doesn’t write a lot of, “grabbed a coffee and a bagel as I walked to the thoat saddle shop. That cute girl from Gathol was there again, even gave me a little smile. Maybe I should talk to her tomorrow. ” I’d love to read more “what’s it like stuff”.

Anyways, do you guys remember this about Helium ? – the roads are all red swards and cars are low flying fliers that go over or under at intersections. Morning is quiet with gentle music and Barsoomian Babes come out to lounge on their balconies while their slaves fix breakfast. And there are bullet trains between the two cities. Oh, and the rising and falling homes on pillars which never made any sense to me since they have fliers. I have noticed mushroomy shaped buildings in the movie trailer by the way. I didn’t either.

Glancing at the contents of Thuvia ( which I haven’t read for ages) I see there are chapters with banths, tharks, white apes , bowmen – halls of doom. I’m wondering if it at 157 pages it is just a tighter book than Chessmen. Good parts only. – Jeff

20110909-085641.jpg

Advertisements

4 responses

  1. Ralok

    my only problem with thuvia is that it came before the chessmen

    hear me out, if it came after chessmen . . . . then both books would be better (both are great of course, but they could have been better)

    it comes down to the race introduced and explored in both books

    kaldanes are probable one of the best things ever to happen to mars, alien bodies, alien way of life, alien ideals . . . .just . . . alien. Not to mention great mental powers

    that is the problem though

    I cannot be impressed with the kaldanes mental abilities, when in the last book I just read about men capable of generating armies and living beings with their minds alone

    September 10, 2011 at 9:14 am

  2. Bard of Helium

    I’m working my way through the series again. Kar Komak has always stuck with me as just a phenomenal bit of imagining. (Pun intended?)

    September 10, 2011 at 11:05 pm

    • Ralok

      when a being in form functions as a human being, when it consumes food and the illusion carries out the function of actuality . .. . it will begin to form cells from what it consumes

      that is my theory, taht the illusion was of such depth . . . that it became real, because it functioned exactly thus

      doesnt fit the canon too well though does it

      September 11, 2011 at 4:25 pm

      • You shouldn’t be drinking on your own man.

        September 11, 2011 at 11:36 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s